中草药对断奶仔猪生长性能影响的Meta分析

doi:10.11843/j.issn.0366-6964.2020.04.023

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 利用Meta分析方法对已发表的中草药在断奶仔猪阶段应用试验研究进行评价，为断奶仔猪保健治疗提供参考。通过计算机检索CNKI、Wanfang Data、Science Direct、Web of Science、VIP数据库，全面收集中草药在断奶仔猪阶段添加的对照试验。采用Cochrane协作网推荐的Review Manager 5.3软件对各效应指标进行Meta分析。共纳入27篇文献，1 870头仔猪，试验组935头，对照组935头，试验组均采用中药治疗，对照组采用金霉素、硫酸黏杆菌素、硫酸黏杆菌素+杆菌肽锌等抗生素治疗。结果显示：中药组对日增重的影响优于整体抗生素组[SMD=1.22，95% CI（0.69~1.75），P<0.01]，但与金霉素组统计学无差异（P>0.05）；中药组日采食量优于整体抗生素组[SMD=0.77，95% CI（0.34~1.20），P<0.01]，但与金霉素组作用相当（P=0.05）；中药组和抗生素组的料重比差异不显著[SMD=-0.35，95% CI（-0.78~0.09），P=0.12>0.05]，但显著优于硫酸黏杆菌素和金霉素亚组（P<0.01）；中药组的腹泻率极显著低于抗生素组{SMD=-1.77，95% CI[-2.52~（-1.01）]，P<0.01}，但与硫酸黏杆菌素+杆菌肽锌组相比，效果相当（P>0.05）。仔猪断奶阶段添加中草药，在日增重、日采食量、腹泻率指标上优于抗生素组，即中药在断奶仔猪阶段研究具有重要潜力。

关键词: 断奶仔猪, 生长性能, Meta分析, 中草药

Abstract: The published clinical trial about treatment of weaned piglet stage with Chinese herbal medicine were systemically evaluated by meta-analysis method, in order to provide valuable reference for treatment of weaning piglet health care. The clinical randomised controlled trials (RCTs) about treatment were searched completely from databases of Science Direct, Web of Science, CNKI, Wanfang Database, VIP Database, etc, using the Review Manager 5.3 software recommended by the Cochrane Collaboration. A total of 27 RCTs and 1 870 weaned piglets were included, among them, 935 weaned piglets in treatment group treated with Chinese herbal medicine, 935 weaned piglets in control group treated with chlortetracycline, colistin sulfate, colistin sulfate + bacitracin zinc. Results showed that:the daily weight gain effect of Chinese medicine group was better than the overall antibiotic group[SMD=1.22, 95%CI(0.69-1.75), P<0.01], but there is no difference with the chlortetracycline group(P>0.05). The daily feed intake of Chinese medicine group was better than the overall antibiotic group[SMD=0.77, 95%CI (0.34-1.20), P<0.01], but equivalent to the chlortetracycline group (P=0.05).The difference in Feed weight ratio between the Chinese medicine group and the antibiotic group was not significant[SMD=-0.35, 95%CI(-0.78-0.09), P=0.12>0.05], However, it was significantly better than the colistin sulfate and chlortetracycline subgroup (P<0.01).The effect of Chinese medicine on diarrhea rate was significantly lower than antibiotics{SMD=-1.77, 95%CI[-2.52-(-1.01)], P<0.01}, However, the effect was comparable to that of the colistin sulfate + bacitracin group (P>0.05). The Chinese herbal medicine was added at the weaning stage of the piglets. The indexes of daily gain, daily feed intake and diarrhea rate were superior to that of the antibiotic group, that is, the traditional Chinese medicine has the potential of traditional Chinese medicine in the stage of weaning piglets.

Key words: weaned piglets, growth performance, Meta-analysis, Chinese herbal medicine

中图分类号:

申远航, 黄晓灵, 高利伟, 曹礼华, 吕航, 郑业鲁, 王众. 中草药对断奶仔猪生长性能影响的Meta分析[J]. 畜牧兽医学报, 2020, 51(4): 861-872.

SHEN Yuanhang, HUANG Xiaoling, GAO Liwei, CAO Lihua, Lü Hang, ZHENG Yelu, WANG Zhong. Effect of Chinese Herbal Medicine on the Growth Performance of Weaned Piglets by Meta-analysis[J]. Acta Veterinaria et Zootechnica Sinica, 2020, 51(4): 861-872.

参考文献 39

[1]	刘颖.仔猪生理特点[J]. 新农业, 2017(1):47.LIU Y. Physiological characteristics of piglets[J]. New Agriculture, 2017(1):47. (in Chinese)
[2]	赵昕红, 李德发, 田福刚, 等. 高锌和高铜对仔猪生长性能、免疫功能和抗氧化酶活性的影响[J]. 中国农业大学学报, 1999, 4(1):91-96.ZHAO X H, LI D F, TIAN F G, et al. Effect of high level of zinc and copper on piglet growth performance, immune response and blood antioxidative enzyme activities in blood[J]. Journal of China Agricultural University, 1999, 4(1):91-96. (in Chinese)
[3]	王婧, 陈晓兰, 王妲妲, 等. 中草药添加剂对断奶仔猪生长性能和免疫功能影响的研究[J]. 中国饲料, 2018(20):32-35.WANG J, CHEN X L, WANG D D, et al. Effects of Chinese herbal additives on growth performance and immune function of weaned piglets[J]. China Feed, 2018(20):32-35. (in Chinese)
[4]	马玉芳, 刘建成, 黄一帆, 等. 中药饲料添加剂对仔猪生长性能和免疫功能的影响[J]. 福建畜牧兽医, 2003, 25(S1):14-16.MA Y F, LIU J C, HUANG Y F, et al. Effect of Chinese herb feed additives on the growth performance and immune function of piglets[J]. Fujian Journal of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Medicine, 2003, 25(S1):14-16. (in Chinese)
[5]	刘鸣. 系统评价、Meta-分析设计与实施方法[M]. 北京:人民卫生出版社, 2011.LIU M. Systematic review, Meta-analysis design and implementation method[M]. Beijing:People's Medical Publishing House, 2011. (in Chinese)
[6]	杨海峰, 何宏勇, 陈海峰, 等. 刺五加提取物对断奶仔猪生长性能、免疫功能和肠道菌群的影响[J]. 中国饲料, 2019(2):45-48.YANG H F, HE H Y, CHEN H F, et al. Effects of Acanthopanax senticosus extract on growth performance, immune function and intestinal flora in weaned piglets[J]. China Feed, 2019(2):45-48. (in Chinese)
[7]	宋延飞, 张鹏, 夏凡. 加味郁金散对断奶仔猪生长性能及血清免疫指标的影响[J]. 中国饲料, 2018(9):52-55.SONG Y F, ZHANG P, XIA F. Effect of Jiawei Yujin San on growth performance and serum immune indexes of weaned piglets[J]. China Feed, 2018(9):52-55. (in Chinese)
[8]	徐明涛. 杜仲叶和八角提取物对断奶仔猪小肠中Ghrelin、Hsp70和PCNA表达的影响[D]. 泰安:山东农业大学, 2018.XU M T. Effects of Eucommia ulmoides leaves and Illicium verum extracts on the expression of Ghrelin, Hsp70 and PCNA in small intestine of weaned piglets[D]. Tai'an:Shandong Agricultural University, 2018. (in Chinese)
[9]	陈畅. 中草药添加剂对断奶仔猪生产性能、血清生化指标、粪中菌群指标的影响[D]. 沈阳:沈阳农业大学, 2017.CHEN C. Effects of Chinese herbal medicine additives on production performance, serum biochemical index and fecal flora index in weaned piglets[D]. Shenyang:Shenyang Agricultural University, 2017. (in Chinese)
[10]	陈丽. 黄褐毛忍冬提取物对早期断奶仔猪生长性能、免疫功能和肠道菌群的影响[D]. 贵阳:贵州师范大学, 2017.CHEN L. Effect of Lonicera fulvotomentosa extract on growth performance, immune function and intestinal flora of weaned piglets[D]. Guiyang:Guizhou Normal University, 2017. (in Chinese)
[11]	马双昆, 僧晓兰, 刘艳芳, 等. 峨眉雪胆微丸对断奶仔猪生产性能及腹泻的影响[J]. 四川农业大学学报, 2015, 33(1):84-88.MA S K, SENG X L, LIU Y F, et al. Effects of Emei hemsleya pellets additives on growth performance and diarrhea parameter of weaning piglets[J]. Journal of Sichuan Agricultural University, 2015, 33(1):84-88. (in Chinese)
[12]	崔世贵, 谢月华, 周树春, 等. 复方中草药对苏淮猪断奶仔猪生产性能的影响[J]. 上海畜牧兽医通讯, 2015(4):42-43.CUI S G, XIE Y H, ZHOU S C, et al. Effect of compound Chinese herbal medicine on performance of weaned piglets in Suhuai pigs[J]. Shanghai Journal of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Medicine, 2015(4):42-43. (in Chinese)
[13]	叶瑞兴. "加味二术散"对断奶仔猪生产性能、血液流变学及小肠抗损伤能力的影响研究[D]. 成都:四川农业大学, 2014.YE R X. The effect of two macrocephala flavored powder on growth performance, hemorheological parameters and small intestine alamage resistance capcities of weaning piglet[D]. Chengdu:Sichuan Agricultural University, 2014. (in Chinese)
[14]	孙玉华. 添加中草药对断奶仔猪生产性能及经济效益的影响[J]. 中国畜牧兽医, 2014, 41(6):108-111.SUN Y H. Effect of Chinese herbal medicine on production performance and economic benefits of weaning piglets[J]. China Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Medicine, 2014, 41(6):108-111. (in Chinese)
[15]	刁新平, 陈美霞, 叶应建, 等. 发酵金樱子对断奶仔猪生长和免疫性能的影响[J]. 东北农业大学学报, 2014, 45(6):67-73.DIAO X P, CHEN M X, YE Y J, et al. Effect of fermented Rosa laevigata michx on growth and immune func-tion of weaned piglets[J]. Journal of Northeast Agricultural University, 2014, 45(6):67-73. (in Chinese)
[16]	黄敏, 胡晓芬, 吴晓明, 等. 加减四君子汤对仔猪免疫机能及生产性能的影响[J]. 中兽医医药杂志, 2014, 33(3):17-21.HUANG M, HU X F, WU X M, et al. Effect of modified Sijunzi decoction on immune function and production performance of weaning piglets[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Veterinary Medicine, 2014, 32(3):17-21. (in Chinese)
[17]	刁新平, 王利军, 陈美霞, 等. 发酵白术对断奶仔猪生长性能和血清生化免疫指标的影响[J]. 东北农业大学学报, 2014, 45(10):64-73.DIAO X P, WANG L J, CHEN M X, et al. Effect of fermented Atractylodes on growth performance and blood biochemical and immuneindices of weaned piglets[J]. Journal of Northeast Agricultural University, 2014, 45(10):64-73. (in Chinese)
[18]	黄达军. 复合中草药多糖对断奶仔猪生产性能的影响[J]. 畜禽业, 2013(3):32-34.HUANG D J. Effect of compound Chinese herbal medicine polysaccharides on production performance of weaned piglets[J]. Livestock and Poultry Industry, 2013(3):32-34. (in Chinese)
[19]	李国柱, 陈灏, 林广基. 中草药制剂苦木汤对仔猪生产性能的影响试验[J]. 广东畜牧兽医科技, 2014, 39(1):13-15.LI G Z, CHEN H, LIN G J. Experimental study on the effect of Chinese herbal medicine Kumu Decoction on the performance of piglets[J]. Guangdong Journal of Animal and Veterinary Science, 2014, 39(1):13-15. (in Chinese)
[20]	刘纪方, 刘萍. 复方中草药对断奶仔猪生产性能和免疫功能的影响[J]. 山东畜牧兽医, 2012, 33(5):8-9.LIU J F, LIU P. Effect of compound Chinese herbal medicine on performance and immune function of weaned piglets[J]. Shandong Journal of Animal Science and Veterinary Medicine, 2012, 33(5):8-9. (in Chinese)
[21]	侯宏伟. 超微粉碎中草药饲料添加剂对断奶仔猪生长性能和血液生化指标的影响[D]. 杨凌:西北农林科技大学, 2010.HOU H W. The effect of ultrafine crushed Chinese herbal medicine feed additives on growth performance and blood biochemical indexes of weaned piglets[D]. Yangling:Northwest A&F University, 2010. (in Chinese)
[22]	吴超, 张莉, 吴跃明, 等. 中草药添加剂对早期断奶仔猪生长性能和肠道菌群的影响[J]. 中国畜牧杂志, 2010, 46(3):31-35, 52.WU C, ZHANG L, WU Y M, et al. Effects of Chinese herb additives on growth performance and intestinal microflora of weaned piglets[J]. Chinese Journal of Animal Science, 2010, 46(3):31-35, 52. (in Chinese)
[23]	朱志刚, 胡建刚, 章华其, 等. 中草药添加剂防治断奶仔猪腹泻和促生长效果试验[J]. 浙江畜牧兽医, 2011, 36(2):27-28.ZHU Z G, HU J G, ZHANG H Q, et al. Effect of Chinese herb additives on diarrhea and growth in piglets[J]. Zhejiang Journal Animal Science and Veterinary Medicine, 2011, 36(2):27-28. (in Chinese)
[24]	汤国海, 蔡伟中, 秦凯, 等. 中草药复方饲料添加剂预防早期断奶仔猪腹泻[J]. 中兽医学杂志, 2008(1):6-8.TANG G H, CAI W Z, QIN K, et al. Chinese herbal medicine compound feed additive for preventing early weaning piglet diarrhea[J]. Chinese Journal of Traditional Veterinary Science, 2008(1):6-8. (in Chinese)
[25]	尹富贵, 孔祥峰, 刘合军, 等. 中草药对仔猪生长性能和血清生化参数的影响[J]. 中国科学院研究生院学报, 2007, 24(2):201-206.YIN F G, KONG X F, LIU H J, et al. Effects of Chinese herbal formula on growth performance and serum biochemical parameters in weaned piglets[J]. Journal of the Graduate School of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2007, 24(2):201-206. (in Chinese)
[26]	董灿娟. 中草药复方的筛选及其对断奶仔猪生长的影响[D]. 杭州:浙江大学, 2007.DONG C J. Screening of Chinese herbal medicine compound and its effect on the growth of weaned piglets[D]. Hangzhou:Zhejiang University, 2007. (in Chinese)
[27]	刘建高. 中草药复方饲料添加剂在断奶仔猪上的应用研究[D]. 长沙:中国科学院亚热带农业生态研究所, 2007.LIU J G. Application study of Chinese herbal formula as dietary additive in weaned piglets[D]. Changsha:The Institute of Subtropical Agriculture, The Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2007. (in Chinese)
[28]	王南明, 张贤芬, 路建忠, 等. 中草药复方饲料添加剂对早期断奶仔猪生长性能的影响[C]//华东区第十七次中兽医科研协作与学术研讨会论文汇编. 上海:中国畜牧兽医学会, 上海市畜牧兽医站, 华东区中兽医研究会, 2006:176-178.WANG N M, ZHANG X F, LU Jianzhong, et al. Effects of Chinese herbal compound feed additives on growth performance of early weaned piglets[C]//East China District Chinese Veterinary Scientific Research Collaboration and Academic Symposium. Shanghai:China Society of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Medicine, Shanghai Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Station, East China Veterinary Research Association, 2006:176-178. (in Chinese)
[29]	王莉. 一种抗菌促生长中药组合物及其制备方法和检测方法:中国, 109674870A[P]. 2019-04-26.WANG L. Antibacterial and growth-prompting traditional Chinese medicine composition as well as preparation method and detection method thereof:CN, 109674870A[P]. 2019-04-26. (in Chinese)
[30]	李志强, 葛长荣, 田允波, 等. 中草药添加剂对哺乳仔猪生长性能的影响(Ⅰ)[J]. 云南农业大学学报, 2002, 17(1):59-62.LI Z Q, GE C R, TIAN Y B, et al. Effect of Chinese herb feed additives on the growing charateristics in piglets(Ⅰ)[J]. Journal of Yunnan Agricultural University, 2002, 17(1):59-62. (in Chinese)
[31]	黄一帆, 姚金水, 马玉芳, 等. 猪保健和促长中药添加剂:中国, 101007090A[P]. 2007-08-01.HUANG Y F, YAO J S, MA Y F, et al. Health-preserving and growth-promoting Chinese medicinal additive for pig:CN, 101007090A[P]. 2007-08-01. (in Chinese)
[32]	胡健, 王燕. 复方中草药添加剂对断奶仔猪生产性能、免疫及抗氧化能力的影响[J]. 饲料博览, 2018(8):1-6.HU J, WANG Y. Effect of the compound Chinese herbal medicine additive on growth performance, immunity and antioxidation of weaned piglets[J]. Feed Review, 2018(8):1-6. (in Chinese)
[33]	张业怀, 凌丁, 梁珠民, 等. 复方白术中草药超微粉添加剂对断奶仔猪生长及防腹泻效果的影响[J]. 黑龙江畜牧兽医, 2018(12):18-21.ZHANG Y H, LING D, LIANG Z M, et al. Effect of compound Atractylodes chinensis ultrafine powder additive on growth and antidiarrheal effect of weaned piglets[J]. Heilongjiang Animal Science and Veterinary Medicine, 2018(12):18-21. (in Chinese)
[34]	武洪志, 宋玉卓, 王志龙, 等. 发酵复方中草药对断奶仔猪生长性能、免疫和生化指标的影响[J]. 东北农业大学学报, 2017, 48(8):15-24.WU H Z, SONG Y Z, WANG Z L, et al. Effect of fermented compound Chinese herbal medicine on growth performance, immune and biochemical indices of weaned piglets[J]. Journal of Northeast Agricultural University, 2017, 48(8):15-24. (in Chinese)
[35]	方潇, 丁晓萍, 昝俊峰, 等. 茯苓皮化学成分及药理作用研究进展[J]. 亚太传统医药, 2019, 15(1):187-191.FANG X, DING X P, ZAN J F, et al. Research progress on chemical constituents and pharmacological effects of Poria cutis[J]. Asia-Pacific Traditional Medicine, 2019, 15(1):187-191. (in Chinese)
[36]	封若雨, 朱新宇, 张苗苗. 近五年山楂眼里作用研究进展[J]. 中国中医药基础学杂志, 2019, 25(5):715-718.FENG R Y, ZHU X Y, ZHANG M M. Research progress on the effects of hawthorn in the past five years[J]. China Journal of Basic Medicine, 2019, 25(5):715-718. (in Chinese)
[37]	谢小全. 健脾开胃颗粒对胃肠功能的影响及机理探讨[D]. 长沙:湖南中医药大学, 2006.XIE X Q. Effect of Jianpi Kaiwei granules on gastrointestinal function and its mechanism[D]. Changsha:Hunan University of Chinese Medicine, 2006. (in Chinese)
[38]	董世山, 蔡辉益, 刘作华, 等. 几种中药复方提取物对仔猪腹泻的防治作用及相关机理[J]. 中国农业大学学报, 2005, 10(3):60-64.DONG S S, CAI H Y, LIU Z H, et al. Antidiarrheal effects and mechanisms of several Chinese medicinal herb extractions[J]. Journal of China Agricultural University, 2005, 10(3):60-64. (in Chinese)
[39]	KARAMI N, MARTNER A, ENNE V I, et al. Transfer of an ampicillin resistance gene between two Escherichia coli strains in the bowel microbiota of an infant treated with antibiotics[J]. J Antimicrob Chemother, 2007, 60(5):1142-1145.